

I thought I had seen the worst when Michael Johns was voted off two weeks ago. But Carly Smithson whips out her most rocking performance yet, and yet she was voted off! The same week Jason Castro poorly sang another song while employing his two signature expressions (which I like to call “constipated” and “relieved”). The same week that Brooke (yet again) messed up the beginning of her song — Jesus Christ Superstar, woman! You’re worse than Archuleta!

The worst part is the nagging suspicion that she lost votes because her song goes “Jesus Christ, superstar, do you think you’re what they say you are?” And I thought I could escape national despair by watching reality TV!
Carly, oh Carly. I weep for you. Facing unnecessarily cruel judges. A nation that hates you and loves “God Bless the USA.” And yet you soldiered on, keeping a smile on your face even as you, one of the two best vocalists this season, ended up in the bottom three time and again.
And I’m left wondering why I keep watching this stupid show. Elliott Yamin, Melinda Doolittle, and now Carly Smithson — I’m 0 for 3 so far.
My only hope is that Carly gets signed right away, and comes back with an album that’s all drunken hellfire and blasphemy. I’ll take the first hundred copies.
Prescription pad:
Jason Castro — Dulcolax, suppository form. Enema if constipation persists.
Brooke White — Xanax, once a day and before performing, talking to judges, or being on camera.
Carly Smithson — a bottle of whiskey and a microphone. Take as needed.